BYU-Idaho or BYU-Provo in Utah?

As a disclaimer, I'm writing as a BYU-Provo student. I honestly never considered going to BYU-Idaho even though many of my friends did. Why? Because BYU-Idaho has yet to establish a reputable four-year university. After getting a degree from BYU, I recognize that degrees mean very little unless the degree is Ivy League, but there's definitely a difference in the quality of education that accompanies the degree, depending on the institution. I cannot speak for BYU-Idaho, its education, or its professors, but I can say that BYU-Provo provides a better education for the price than BYU-Idaho does. You could try proving the opposite, but the only reasoning that would hold any water would be class size differential, which isn't even that great.

Location was the other major factor for me. Idaho is nice. I used to live there. However, given the fact that I knew I wanted to attend a church school, I wanted to be more centrally located to opportunity, which I find more of in Utah Valley than in Idaho. Don't believe me? Just look at any Utah directory and you'll see that there are many businesses, large and small, providing opportunities for work, learning, and growth to BYU students - many more here than in Idaho. People who go to BYU-Idaho obviously have reasons for doing so, but for my life goals and ambitions, I think I chose well.

Comments




  • And how exactly do you define a quality education? From a college centered in a thriving metropolis?


    I can say that BYU-Idaho offers an excellent education for the price, and this is why: the quality of one's education is not determined by class size, professors, local opportunities for personal enrichment. It is determined by the amount of blood, sweat, and tears that one is willing to invest in one's education. Abe Lincoln was a failure in law school his first try, so he went home. He studied Euclid until he could give all 70 of the propositions from memory. Then he went back, and he became such an excellent logician that a colleague said of him that when Lincoln argued his case, he was so logical that though you disagreed completely, you couldn't argue with him. Lincoln did not get this quality from his law school-- he got it himself. You can get a world-class education no matter where you go to school. It all depends on you. Your statement is ridiculous, presumptuous, and arrogant. I often find that to be the attitude of Provo students. I was accepted to both schools, and chose Idaho. My main reason was size. But the quality of my education would have been the same in either place, because I am the same person no matter where I go.


     

    Aubrie, 3 years ago | Flag
  • You may think I'm a typical scorned BYU-Idaho student who couldn't make it into Provo, but that's not the case. I chose to come here (and could've gone to Provo). I think both schools are great, but your argument that companies would hire a Provo student over Idaho just based on the school they went to holds little water. Any employer outside of Utah/Idaho will probably think they are the same thing really.


    My brother went to school at Idaho and now has a great job working at the Hannford nuclear reactor site in the Tri-city area in Washington state. I think experience and determination matter more to employers than JUST an education.


    As far as social life, I think Provo is way better. Hands down. The only thing I don't appreciate is when someone from Provo thinks they're better just because they go there.


     

    Shaws, 3 years ago | Flag
  • Speaking as someone who plans on transfering from BYU-Idaho to Provo.  Your post has absolutely no merit, whatsoever...  Seriously, your entire point is lost when you say "I don't know anything about BYU-I's education or professors, but Provo's is better!"


    Really?  How would you know that Provo's is better if you don't know anything about BYU-Idahos educational system?  Your argument makes about much sense as saying one apple taste better than another, despite only tasting one of them and not even trying the second.  Is that the kind of fallacy based logic they teach at BYU-Provo?  If you don't know anything about a certain institution, you just assume that yours is better?  Do you have any actual reasoning behind this besides your own cognitive dissonance? 


    Maybe, if you actually used a fact based example to back up your claim, your point would have some substance, but instead you just come off as a jerk who is trying to insult the students here at Rexburg and brag about how much greater your school is.  I guess thats the kind of idiocentric teaching I can expect back in Happy Valley...

    bmdevine, 3 years ago | Flag

Inappropriate Flag

Flagging notifies the iComm Student Media webmaster of inappropriate content. Please flag any messages that violate the Terms of Service. Please include a short explanation why you're flagging this message. Thank you!

If you believe this content violates the Terms of Service, please write a short description why. Thank you.

Inappropriate Comment Flag

Flagging notifies the iComm Student Media webmaster of inappropriate content. Please flag any messages that violate the Terms of Service. Please include a short explanation why you're flagging this message. Thank you!

Email Friends

Your First Name (optional)

Email Addresses (comma separated)

Import friends

Message to Friends (optional)

Are you human?

Or, you can forward this blog with your own email application.

Terms of Service

mock rpx login link